What is an intern
What is an Intern Under South African Labour Law
Understanding what is an intern within the South African context is crucial for both employers and aspiring professionals who wish to gain valuable work experience. South Africa’s labour environment comprises a mix of statutory regulations, common law principles, and guidelines provided by bodies such as the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). The term “intern” is commonly understood as a person who seeks exposure to the workplace, often for a limited duration, and usually with the goal of obtaining practical experience in a particular profession or field of study. However, in South African Labour Law, there are specific implications attached to this status, arising from legislation such as the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (hereafter LRA), the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 (hereafter BCEA), and the Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 (hereafter SDA).
The legal framework ensures that interns receive protection and fair treatment, while also defining the obligations of employers. In practice, the question “What is an intern?” points to a relationship that can range from purely experiential learning to a formally contracted arrangement akin to employment. If an internship is structured as a form of skill development or on-the-job training, it can be governed by statutory frameworks providing minimum standards of protection, such as working hours and compensation. But if the internship strays beyond a learning environment and the intern performs tasks akin to those of regular employees, the law may classify the individual as an employee—triggering additional legal obligations for the employer.
South African case law and legislation have evolved to protect the rights of interns and to ensure that employers do not exploit internship arrangements. Given the country’s pressing need for skills development and youth employment, internships have become an essential gateway to professional growth. Yet, confusion often arises when these arrangements blur the line between learner and employee. It is therefore vital to evaluate the term “What is an intern?” in the light of how South African law treats issues of contract formation, remuneration, hours of work, and statutory benefits.
The remainder of this article explores the historical context, legal framework, contractual aspects, rights, and obligations attached to interns. By weaving through relevant authorities and case law, this discussion aims to offer clarity on “What is an intern?” under South African Labour Law, highlighting the practical implications for both interns and employers.
The Historical Context of Internships in South Africa
Although the term “What is an intern?” may appear modern, its roots lie in the longstanding apprenticeship and learnership systems that have existed in various forms throughout history. In pre-democratic South Africa, formal apprenticeship was often regulated by industry-specific legislation, limiting access and opportunities primarily to a select demographic group. As the new constitutional era dawned post-1994, emphasis was placed on improving access to education, training, and skill development.
Internships, unlike traditional apprenticeships, were born from the notion of short-term or flexible training opportunities that could accommodate students, graduates, or individuals seeking practical experience. The Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 was introduced to promote a culture of learning and to align skills development with national economic needs. Through the SDA, the concept of experiential learning in the workplace became synonymous with addressing youth unemployment, bridging the skills gap, and fostering economic growth.
The historical journey of “What is an intern?” in South Africa therefore ties back to these legislative measures and the broader socio-economic transformation agenda. While learnerships remain more structured and regulated, internships have gradually evolved into a broad framework for work-based experience. This lack of a universally standardised internship definition can lead to misunderstandings about the rights and duties of both interns and employers.
The Legal Framework Governing Interns
“What is an intern?” often hinges on how South African law classifies individuals within the labour market. The LRA, the BCEA, and the SDA serve as the primary pillars that guide this classification, together with common law contractual principles.
Under section 200A of the LRA, an individual who renders services to another is presumed to be an employee under certain conditions, unless the contrary is proven. This presumption can extend to those who are called interns if the reality of the working relationship shows elements of typical employment, such as subordination, supervision, or receipt of remuneration in exchange for work performed.
The BCEA sets basic conditions of employment relating to working hours, leave, remuneration, and other entitlements. Interns who qualify as employees under the LRA might be covered by the BCEA if their roles go beyond mere training. If, however, the intern is genuinely a learner within the meaning of the SDA, some provisions of the BCEA might not strictly apply, although the SDA itself provides certain protections.
The Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 encourages structured workplace learning programs. While the Act does not always refer explicitly to interns, the concept of “learnerships” and “skills programs” can overlap with internship models. Where an intern is engaged via an official skills development program, the SDA’s terms on allowances, program duration, and certification of learning may apply.
Given these intersecting pieces of legislation, whether a person is truly an intern is not solely a matter of nomenclature, but rather the substance of the relationship. Whether or not an individual is classified as an employee will depend on the facts of each case, guided by relevant case law and statutory definitions.
Contractual Aspects of Internships
Contractual principles play a pivotal role in answering the question, “What is an intern?” under South African law. An intern’s legal status can stem from a formal internship agreement, a casual arrangement, or an oral understanding. Courts and tribunals look at the nature of the agreement and the conduct of the parties to determine whether an employment relationship exists.
Employers sometimes present internship agreements that specify the learning objectives, duration of the internship, remuneration (if any), and other conditions of work. Where the agreement highlights skills transfer as the primary objective, and the intern receives only a stipend or an allowance to cover basic expenses, the arrangement might lean towards a training relationship rather than traditional employment.
However, if the intern’s tasks include the full range of duties similar to permanent employees, the lines become blurred. In such cases, the intern may be deemed an employee for purposes of the LRA and the BCEA. The presence of subordination, control, supervision, and accountability often speaks to an employment relationship.
In certain scenarios, the CCMA or the Labour Court will assess the reality of the situation. Employers who mislabel employees as interns to sidestep statutory obligations may face legal challenges, penalties, and orders for retrospective compensation. Conversely, a bona fide internship agreement that prioritises skill development and a learning component can remain within the realm of a training relationship, provided it aligns with statutory guidelines.
Rights and Obligations of Interns
When one asks, “What is an intern?” the immediate issues that follow are the scope of rights and obligations for the intern. In genuine internship arrangements that do not cross the threshold into employment, the intern may not be entitled to the full suite of employee benefits such as annual leave, sick leave, or retirement contributions.
Yet, certain statutory protections can still apply to interns. Health and safety regulations under the Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993 extend to all persons in the workplace, including interns, ensuring that they are not exposed to undue risk. The prohibition of unfair discrimination under the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 also applies, guaranteeing equality in recruitment and workplace conditions.
Once an individual is deemed an employee, the rights broaden significantly. They may be entitled to minimum wage (where sectoral determinations apply), unemployment insurance contributions, and other benefits. The obligations of an intern who is classified as an employee mirror those of any worker: adhering to work rules, performing tasks diligently, and respecting the employer’s disciplinary code.
Where the internship is strictly for learning, interns have the obligation to participate in training activities and respect the legitimate operational requirements of the host organisation. Employers, for their part, must provide genuine mentoring and training opportunities, ensuring that the primary purpose of the engagement is educational, rather than simply obtaining cheap labour.
Implications for Employers and Interns
Understanding “What is an intern?” is not merely an academic exercise; it carries tangible implications for both parties involved. For interns, it affects their legal protection, remuneration, and career development trajectory. For employers, it speaks to compliance with labour laws, potential exposure to litigation, and reputational risk.
If an employer misclassifies a worker who is performing critical organisational tasks as an intern, labour tribunals may order the payment of outstanding wages, benefits, and even compensation for unfair labour practices. Employers may also find themselves liable for contributions to statutory funds, such as the Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF).
On the positive side, a properly structured internship offers the employer an avenue to develop young talent and evaluate future employees without fully committing to a permanent employment relationship. Interns, in turn, gain practical insight, networking opportunities, and a clearer sense of career direction.
Maintaining clarity in contracts and abiding by the relevant legislation minimises disputes. It is prudent for employers to develop a comprehensive internship policy outlining the scope, duration, and educational components of the internship. This helps to avoid confusion about “What is an intern?” and to protect both parties from misunderstandings.
The Role of the CCMA in Internship Disputes
The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) stands at the forefront of resolving labour disputes, including those concerning interns. If a dispute arises—such as an intern alleging unfair dismissal or unfair labour practice—the CCMA may step in to assess the intern’s status and the nature of the dispute.
When the CCMA examines “What is an intern?” it applies statutory definitions and tests, such as the dominant impression test. This test weighs multiple factors including supervision, control over work hours, obligation to render services, and level of dependence on the employer. If these factors collectively point towards an employment relationship, the intern is likely to be deemed an employee, granting them rights under the LRA.
The CCMA proceedings often begin with conciliation, where the parties attempt to reach a settlement. If unresolved, the matter proceeds to arbitration, and the arbitrator’s findings can be taken on review to the Labour Court. Employers who fail to align their internship practices with legal requirements risk negative awards, including reinstatement orders or compensation for the intern.
Case Law Illustrations on Intern Rights
South African Labour Courts have periodically addressed disputes concerning interns, clarifying the question, “What is an intern?” through judicial precedents. In some cases, courts have acknowledged that if an internship arrangement closely mimics an employment contract, the intern is entitled to statutory protections. Conversely, where an organisation provides robust training, minimal productive outputs, and no expectation of continued employment, courts often uphold the purely educational nature of the arrangement.
For example, in Discovery Health Ltd v CCMA [2008] 7 BLLR 633 (LC), although not exclusively about interns, the Labour Court reiterated the principle that substance prevails over form in determining employment status. The Court highlighted the importance of examining the totality of the relationship rather than relying solely on the label given to the individual.
The matter of Heavenly Lodges v CCMA (2000) 2 BLLR 234 (LC) demonstrated that a company cannot simply evade obligations by calling a worker a “trainee” or “intern.” If the worker performs full duties and is subject to the employer’s control, the label is not dispositive of the underlying relationship.
Case law thus underscores that the answer to “What is an intern?” lies in the real-life function and the context in which the individual operates, affirming that each matter hinges on its unique facts.
FAQ: Understanding What is an Intern in South African Labour Law
Question: What is an intern in the simplest sense under South African law?
In the simplest sense, an intern is someone who works within an organisation primarily for the sake of obtaining practical training or work exposure. If this individual performs duties comparable to those of a regular employee and meets certain criteria under legislation, they may be considered an employee, triggering the protection of labour laws.
Question: What is an intern’s key distinguishing feature compared to a regular employee?
An intern’s defining feature is the primary focus on acquiring skills and practical experience. While a regular employee is hired primarily to fulfil an organisational need, an intern’s presence is meant to benefit the individual through structured learning, though some overlap in duties may occur.
Question: Can an unpaid internship qualify under South African law?
Unpaid internships can exist, but the employer must ensure that they do not use the arrangement to circumvent labour law obligations. If the individual is performing tasks similar to paid employees for an extended period, the CCMA or Labour Court may classify the intern as an employee who is entitled to compensation.
Question: How can I tell whether an intern is truly an employee?
The CCMA often applies tests such as the dominant impression test. Factors include who controls the working hours, who assigns tasks, whether there is a direct form of remuneration or stipend, and whether the intern is integrated into the employer’s core operations. The analysis must be holistic and fact-specific.
Question: What is an intern’s protection under the Basic Conditions of Employment Act?
If an intern is deemed an employee, they receive the same protection under the BCEA as other employees, including provisions on working hours, leave, and overtime pay (where relevant). If they remain purely in a training capacity, however, their protections may be more limited.
Question: Do interns have to pay UIF (Unemployment Insurance Fund) contributions?
If an intern qualifies as an employee, both the employer and the intern must contribute to UIF. In purely training-based internships that do not cross the threshold into employment, UIF contributions might not apply. However, each case depends on its specific facts.
Question: What is an intern’s right to fair labour practices?
Under the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, everyone has the right to fair labour practices. If an intern is classified as an employee, the LRA protects them against unfair dismissal and unfair labour practices. Even as a learner, certain protections—like non-discrimination—still apply.
Question: Can an intern be dismissed without recourse?
If an intern is not an employee, the end of the internship typically signifies the end of the relationship, and no recourse for unfair dismissal exists. But if the intern is deemed an employee, the employer must follow due process for dismissal, including adherence to the LRA’s fair dismissal procedures.
Question: What about confidentiality and trade secrets?
Interns, even if not employees, often gain access to confidential information. Employers typically include confidentiality clauses within internship agreements. This not only protects the employer’s interests but also clarifies the intern’s obligations to respect intellectual property and trade secrets.
Question: Can an internship lead to permanent employment?
Many interns ultimately transition into permanent roles if there is a genuine need within the organisation and if the intern performs satisfactorily. While South African law does not guarantee permanent employment after an internship, a contract or policy stating that strong performance could lead to a job offer is common.
References
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA)
The LRA outlines the definition and rights of employees, including provisions that may apply to interns if they meet the statutory criteria. Section 200A presumes an individual is an employee under certain conditions, which is key to determining whether an intern is an employee in law. - Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 (BCEA)
This Act prescribes the minimum standards of employment, including working hours, leave, and remuneration. If an intern is found to be an employee, they are entitled to these basic protections. - Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 (SDA)
The SDA promotes a culture of learning and focuses on structured workplace-based learning. Although not always explicitly referring to interns, its principles undergird many internship programs by ensuring that the primary purpose is skills development. - Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993 (OHSA)
This legislation safeguards all persons on a business’s premises, including interns, from workplace hazards. It underscores the duty of care employers owe to interns, regardless of employee status. - Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 (EEA)
The EEA addresses issues of discrimination and equality in the workplace. Interns, like all individuals present in the workplace, are entitled to a work environment free from unfair discrimination. - Discovery Health Ltd v CCMA [2008] 7 BLLR 633 (LC)
In this case, while not exclusively about internships, the Labour Court stressed that substance prevails over form. This principle guides tribunals when classifying a purported intern as either a learner or an employee. - Heavenly Lodges v CCMA (2000) 2 BLLR 234 (LC)
This case illustrated that simply labelling a worker as an intern or trainee does not absolve the employer of statutory obligations. The court emphasised examining the actual working relationship, tasks performed, and the level of employer control.
Each of these authorities confirms that classifying “What is an intern?” involves more than applying a label. The courts and statutory bodies focus on the nature of the relationship, the purpose of the engagement, and the protections afforded to individuals who may otherwise be vulnerable to exploitation. These references collectively affirm that interns can benefit from the fundamental rights enshrined in South African labour laws, depending on the factual circumstances of their engagement.
Useful Links
The official website of the Department of Employment and Labour in South Africa offers valuable information about labour legislation, regulations, and updates. This resource is useful for both interns and employers who wish to understand changing policies and guidelines on the labour market.
https://www.labour.gov.za
The CCMA Official Website provides resources and guidelines on dispute resolution, referrals, and how to approach potential intern-related labour disputes. This helps individuals understand the processes involved should they need to escalate a matter regarding an internship.
https://www.ccma.org.za
The SA Government’s Skills Portal is an excellent resource for those looking to enhance or acquire new skills, including internships and learnerships. It gives insight into ongoing initiatives and provides helpful links for career development.
https://www.skillsportal.co.za
For queries regarding the validity of employment contracts click here.
For information about employment rights in the entertainment industry click here.
For information about COIDA claims click here.
For general enforcement of employment rights click here.
For more information about rights in relation to remuneration click here.
For more information about rights during retrenchment click here.
For more information about the fairness of dismissals in absentia click here.
For more information about enforcing restraints of trade click here.
For more information about foreign nationals and working permits click here.
For more information about enforcing a CCMA award click here.
For more information about the right to parental leave click here.
For information about workplace bullying ad harassment click here.
For information about maternity leave click here.
For information about constructive dismissal click here.
For information about unfair labour practices related to training click here,
For queries about legal representation in disciplinary hearings click here.
If your query relates to how UIF is claimed click here.
If your query relates to a matter where the employee in question is a domestic worker click here
If your query relates to whether or not someone is an employee click here.
If you would like to know more about the retrenchment process click here.
If you would like to know more about employees rights during probation click here.
If you would like to know more about the registration of non-profit organisations click here.
This article is a general information sheet and should not be used or relied on as legal or other professional advice. No liability can be accepted for errors, omissions, loss, or damage arising from reliance upon any information herein. Don’t hesitate to contact Meyer and Partners Attorneys Incorporated if you require further information or specific and detailed advice. Errors and omissions excepted (E&OE).