What is constructive dismissal
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5992/b59922c2de0c282dfe5e9bd23677c2fc6fa21577" alt="15 What is constructive dismissal"
Understanding Constructive Dismissal in South African Law: What Is Constructive Dismissal?
So, what is constructive dismissal? It is a critical concept in South African labour law that often leaves both employers and employees grappling with its implications. In essence, it occurs when an employee resigns because the employer has made continued employment intolerable. This article delves into the legal framework surrounding constructive dismissal, its key elements, and the remedies available to affected employees.
The Legal Definition of Constructive Dismissal
To fully grasp whatit is, we turn to the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA). According to Section 186(1)(e) of the LRA, constructive dismissal is defined as a situation where “an employee terminated a contract of employment with or without notice because the employer made continued employment intolerable for the employee.”
This definition underscores that the resignation is not truly voluntary but is forced upon the employee due to the employer’s conduct. The case of Pretoria Society for the Care of the Retarded v Loots (1997) 18 ILJ 981 (LAC) further clarifies that the onus is on the employee to prove that the resignation was not a voluntary act but was, in fact, a dismissal.
Key Elements of Constructive Dismissal
Understanding what it is requires an examination of its key elements:
- Intolerable Working Conditions: The employee must prove that the working conditions were so unbearable that resignation was the only reasonable option.
- Employer’s Conduct: The intolerable conditions must be due to the employer’s actions or omissions.
- No Reasonable Alternative: The employee must demonstrate that there were no viable alternatives to resignation.
In Jooste v Transnet Ltd t/a SA Airways (1995) 16 ILJ 629 (LAC), the court emphasized that the employee must show that the employer’s conduct was the main cause of the resignation.
Proving Constructive Dismissal
Proving constructive dismissal is inherently challenging. The burden of proof lies with the employee, who must provide evidence that:
- The employer made continued employment intolerable.
- The resignation was a direct result of the employer’s conduct.
- There were no reasonable steps that could have been taken to resolve the situation before resigning.
The Labour Appeal Court in Murray v Minister of Defence [2008] ZASCA 44 highlighted the importance of exhausting all internal remedies before opting to resign.
Common Scenarios Leading to Constructive Dismissal
To further understand what constructive dismissal is, consider common scenarios that may lead to such claims:
- Harassment or Bullying: Persistent mistreatment by superiors or colleagues that the employer fails to address.
- Unilateral Changes to Employment Terms: Significant alterations to job roles, remuneration, or working hours without the employee’s consent.
- Discrimination: Unfair treatment based on race, gender, religion, or other prohibited grounds.
- Unsafe Working Conditions: Environments that pose health risks, which the employer neglects to rectify.
- Undue Disciplinary Actions: Unjustified warnings or disciplinary measures aimed at forcing the employee to resign.
Legal Remedies for Constructive Dismissal
Employees who successfully prove constructive dismissal are entitled to remedies under the LRA. These may include:
- Reinstatement: Returning to the former position as if the dismissal never occurred.
- Re-employment: Being employed in a different position.
- Compensation: Monetary awards of up to 12 months’ remuneration for unfair dismissal.
The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) is the primary body that handles such disputes, offering conciliation and arbitration services.
Employer’s Defenses Against Constructive Dismissal Claims
Employers facing constructive dismissal claims can defend themselves by demonstrating that:
- The working conditions were not intolerable.
- Reasonable steps were taken to address the employee’s concerns.
- The employee did not utilize available grievance procedures.
Employers may reference Section 192(2) of the LRA, which stipulates that if the existence of the dismissal is established, the employer must prove that the dismissal was fair.
The Importance of Grievance Procedures
Before resigning, employees are generally expected to exhaust all internal grievance mechanisms. Failure to do so, as noted in Murray v Minister of Defence, may weaken a constructive dismissal claim. Utilizing these procedures demonstrates that the employee sought to resolve the issues amicably.
Impact on Employment Relations
Constructive dismissal claims can strain the employer-employee relationship and have broader implications for workplace morale and reputation. Understanding what it is helps both parties navigate disputes more effectively and fosters a healthier work environment.
Preventive Measures for Employers
Employers can take proactive steps to minimize the risk of constructive dismissal claims:
- Clear Communication: Maintain open channels for employees to voice concerns.
- Policy Enforcement: Implement and enforce policies on harassment, discrimination, and workplace safety.
- Regular Training: Educate management and staff on acceptable workplace conduct.
- Prompt Action: Address grievances swiftly and effectively.
Employee Awareness and Actions
Employees should be aware of their rights and the proper procedures when facing intolerable working conditions:
- Document Incidents: Keep detailed records of all relevant events and communications.
- Seek Advice: Consult with a union representative or legal professional.
- Follow Procedures: Utilize internal grievance mechanisms before considering resignation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Constructive Dismissal
What is constructive dismissal in simple terms?
Constructive dismissal happens when an employee resigns because their employer has made their working conditions unbearable, effectively forcing them to leave.
How do I prove constructive dismissal in South Africa?
You must show that the employer’s conduct made continued employment intolerable, you had no reasonable alternative but to resign, and you resigned as a direct result of the employer’s actions.
Can I claim compensation for constructive dismissal?
Yes, if you prove constructive dismissal, you may be awarded compensation of up to 12 months’ remuneration, reinstatement, or re-employment.
Is there a time limit to file a constructive dismissal claim?
You must refer your dispute to the CCMA within 30 days of the date of dismissal.
Does the employer’s intent matter in constructive dismissal?
The employer’s intent is less important than the effect of their actions. What matters is whether their conduct made continued employment intolerable.
Can changes in my job role lead to constructive dismissal?
Significant unilateral changes to your job role without your consent can constitute constructive dismissal if they make your position intolerable.
Should I resign immediately if I feel constructively dismissed?
It’s advisable to first utilize internal grievance procedures and seek legal advice before resigning, as this can strengthen your claim.
What if I don’t follow grievance procedures?
Not following internal procedures may weaken your claim, as courts expect employees to attempt to resolve issues before resigning.
Can constructive dismissal affect my future employment?
A constructive dismissal claim does not negatively impact your employment record, but potential employers may inquire about the circumstances of your resignation.
Do I need a lawyer to handle a constructive dismissal case?
While not mandatory, legal representation can help navigate the complexities of the case and improve your chances of a favourable outcome.
References
Legal Authority | Substance and Importance |
---|---|
Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) | Provides the legal framework for constructive dismissal, outlining the rights and obligations of employers and employees. |
Section 186(1)(e) of the LRA | Specifically defines constructive dismissal, serving as the basis for legal claims. |
Pretoria Society for the Care of the Retarded v Loots | (1997) 18 ILJ 981 (LAC): Clarifies the onus on the employee to prove that resignation was not voluntary but due to the employer’s conduct. |
Jooste v Transnet Ltd t/a SA Airways | (1995) 16 ILJ 629 (LAC): Emphasizes that the employer’s conduct must be the main cause of the resignation for it to be considered constructive dismissal. |
Murray v Minister of Defence | [2008] ZASCA 44: Highlights the necessity of exhausting internal remedies before resigning and the impact on the legitimacy of a constructive dismissal claim. |
Section 192(2) of the LRA | Places the burden on the employer to prove that the dismissal was fair once a dismissal has been established by the employee. |
Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration | The statutory body responsible for resolving labour disputes, including constructive dismissal cases, offering accessible avenues for employees seeking redress. |
Section 193 of the LRA | Outlines the remedies available for unfair dismissal, guiding the relief granted in constructive dismissal cases, such as reinstatement and compensation. |
Useful External Links
Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) – www.ccma.org.za
The CCMA provides resources and guidance on how to file a dispute, the processes involved, and what to expect during conciliation and arbitration.
Department of Employment and Labour – www.labour.gov.za
Offers comprehensive information on labour legislation, workers’ rights, and employer obligations, helping parties understand the legal context of constructive dismissal.
South African Labour Guide – www.labourguide.co.za
Provides practical articles, updates on labour law developments, and advice on handling workplace disputes, beneficial for both employers and employees.
If you have related employment queries consider the links here under:
For queries regarding the validity of employment contracts click here.
For information about employment rights in the entertainment industry click here.
For information about COIDA claims click here.
For general enforcement of employment rights click here.
For more information about rights in relation to remuneration click here.
For more information about rights during retrenchment click here.
For more information about the fairness of dismissals in absentia click here.
For more information about enforcing restraints of trade click here.
For more information about foreign nationals and working permits click here.
For more information about enforcing a CCMA award click here.
For more information about the right to parental leave click here.
For information about workplace bullying ad harassment click here.
For information about maternity leave click here.
For information about unfair labour practices related to training click here,
If you would like to know more about in absentia dismissal click here.
If you would like to know more about the difference between misconduct and incapacity click here.
If your query relates to how UIF is claimed click here.
If your query relates to a matter where the employee in question is a domestic worker click here
If your query relates to whether or not someone is an employee click here.
If you would like to know more about interns and their rights click here.
If you would like to know more about the retrenchment process click here.
If you would like to know more about procedural fairness in disciplinary matters click here.
If you would like to know more about unfair labour practices in general click here.
If you would like to know more about employees rights during probation click here.
This article is a general information sheet and should not be used or relied on as legal or other professional advice. No liability can be accepted for errors, omissions, loss, or damage arising from reliance upon any information herein. Don’t hesitate to contact Meyer and Partners Attorneys Incorporated if you require further information or specific and detailed advice. Errors and omissions excepted (E&OE).