Cession of Contract Rights
Cession of Contract Rights in South African Law
Understanding the Concept of Cession of Contract Rights
In South African law, the cession of contract rights refers to the legal mechanism whereby a creditor (the cedent) transfers their personal right or claim against a debtor to another party (the cessionary). This right is usually a right to performance—most commonly, a right to payment under a contract. Cession does not require the consent of the debtor and does not affect the obligation itself but merely substitutes the creditor.
The Legal Nature of Cession
Cession is a derivative mode of transfer, much like delivery in the case of corporeal property. It is not a novation and does not require a new contract. Instead, cession involves two parties: the cedent and the cessionary, with the debtor often uninvolved. The act of cession is completed through an agreement (the cession agreement) coupled with the intention to transfer the right. See National Bank of South Africa Ltd v Cohen’s Trustee 1911 AD 235.
The Difference Between Cession and Assignment in South African Law
The difference between cession and assignment in South African law is often misunderstood. Assignment, a concept from English law, can involve both rights and obligations. In contrast, South African cession only pertains to rights. Obligations cannot be ceded but must be delegated, which requires the consent of the debtor. Thus, while an assignment can be broader, South African law distinguishes between cession (rights) and delegation (duties).
Requirements for a Valid Cession of Contract Rights
For the cession of contract rights to be valid, several requirements must be met:
- There must be a valid causa or underlying agreement.
- The cedent must have a right capable of being ceded.
- The parties must have the intention to cede.
- The right must not be of a personal nature that precludes transfer (see Hutchison and Pretorius: The Law of Contract in South Africa).
No formalities are required unless specified by statute or agreement. Importantly, the debtor’s consent is not required for the cession to be effective, addressing the common query: can rights be ceded without consent? The answer is yes, although notice to the debtor is advisable to avoid disputes.
Cession of Contractual Rights and Obligations: What Can and Cannot Be Transferred
The cession of contractual rights and obligations must be approached with care. Only rights can be ceded; obligations cannot be transferred via cession. For example, the right to receive payment can be ceded, but the duty to perform under a contract cannot be. Where parties wish to transfer obligations, a separate agreement of delegation or novation must be executed with the debtor’s consent.
Third-Party Rights in a Cession
Third-party rights in a cession primarily concern the debtor and any other entity with an interest in the original contract. Although the debtor’s consent is not needed for a cession to be valid, the debtor retains all defenses available against the original creditor. In Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Oneanate Investments (Pty) Ltd (in Liquidation) 1998 (1) SA 811 (SCA), the court held that the debtor may set up defenses against the cessionary that were available against the cedent at the time of cession.
Practical Examples of Cession of Contract Rights
A practical illustration: Company A (the cedent) has a contract with Customer B (the debtor) for monthly payments. Company A cedes its right to these payments to Bank C (the cessionary) as security for a loan. Customer B continues paying, now to Bank C. The obligation remains unchanged; only the creditor changes. This is a typical example of a cession in securitatem debiti (security cession).
Another example is an outright cession, where Company A sells its debtors’ book to Company D. This is common in factoring agreements, where debtors are ceded to a financier.
Risks Associated With Cession Clauses in Commercial Agreements
Cession clauses can carry significant risks, especially in commercial agreements. Firstly, ambiguity in how to draft a cession clause can lead to litigation. Secondly, if a cession clause attempts to cede both rights and obligations without proper delegation, it can be declared invalid. Thirdly, the existence of competing cessions (double cession) may result in uncertainty as to the rightful cessionary. In Scott v First National Bank 1988 (1) SA 745 (A), the court ruled that the first cession in time generally prevails.
Drafting cession clauses requires clarity and must address:
- The scope of the rights ceded
- The timing of the cession
- Notification requirements to debtors
- Provisions regarding reversion of rights
These considerations are essential for mitigating risks and ensuring enforceability.
The Effect of Cession on Debtors
While a cession of contract rights does not require debtor consent, it impacts the debtor in key ways. The debtor must now perform in favour of the cessionary once notified. Until such notice, payment to the cedent discharges the obligation. The rule was confirmed in Linton v Corser 1922 AD 524. After notice, any payment to the cedent may not discharge the debt and could lead to double liability.
Cession in Securitatem Debiti vs. Outright Cession
Cession may be made in securitatem debiti (as security) or as an outright transfer. In the former, the ceded right reverts to the cedent once the principal obligation is fulfilled. In the latter, it is permanently transferred. The distinction was elaborated in Tuckers Land and Development Corporation v Strydom 1981 (1) SA 740 (T). Failure to correctly describe the type of cession may cause disputes during enforcement or liquidation.
Cession in Insolvency
Upon the insolvency of a cedent, the nature of the cession becomes critical. An outright cession removes the asset from the insolvent estate. However, in a security cession, the right may revert if the debt is settled. In FNB v Lynn NO 1996 (2) SA 339 (A), the court emphasized that the cessionary’s rights depend on whether the cession was absolute or for security.
Formalities and Notification
Although cession generally requires no formalities, failing to notify the debtor can have significant consequences. Notice protects the cessionary against payments made to the cedent and establishes priority over competing cessionaries. For this reason, best practice dictates early notification to all affected parties.
How to Draft a Cession Clause
When considering how to draft a cession clause, key aspects include:
- Clear identification of the cedent and cessionary
- A full description of the ceded rights
- Whether the cession is absolute or for security
- The timing and conditions for transfer
- Remedies in case of breach
Cession clauses should also address the status of the debtor and whether notice will be given. Integration into the main agreement ensures enforceability.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the legal meaning of “cession of contract rights” in South African law?
It refers to the transfer of a personal right by agreement from the cedent to the cessionary, without the need for debtor consent.
Is debtor consent required for a cession?
No. Consent is not required; however, notice is critical to protect the interests of the cessionary.
Can a party cede obligations under a contract?
No. Obligations must be transferred through delegation, which requires the consent of the debtor.
What is the difference between a security cession and an outright cession?
A security cession is temporary and reverts once the debt is paid. An outright cession is a permanent transfer of rights.
What happens if the debtor is not notified of the cession?
The debtor may validly discharge the obligation by paying the original creditor, leaving the cessionary with limited recourse.
Can a debtor raise defences against the cessionary?
Yes. Any defences that were available against the cedent at the time of cession can be raised against the cessionary.
How can multiple cessions of the same right be resolved?
Generally, the first cession in time prevails unless notice and delivery of the instrument suggest otherwise.
Can cession be included as a standard term in a contract?
Yes, and it often is. Proper drafting is crucial to avoid invalidity or ambiguity.
What formalities are needed for a valid cession?
None are required by law unless prescribed by contract or statute. However, a written agreement and notice are advisable.
Can contractual rights be ceded in insolvency?
Yes, but the nature of the cession (security vs. outright) determines whether the asset forms part of the insolvent estate.
References
| Legal Authority | Citation | Discussion |
|---|---|---|
| National Bank of SA Ltd v Cohen’s Trustee | 1911 AD 235 | Defined the nature of cession as a mode of transfer of incorporeal rights. |
| Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Oneanate Investments | 1998 (1) SA 811 (SCA) | Recognized debtor defences against cessionaries. |
| Scott v First National Bank | 1988 (1) SA 745 (A) | Clarified rules on competing cessions. |
| Linton v Corser | 1922 AD 524 | Addressed effect of notice on debtor obligations. |
| Tuckers Land v Strydom | 1981 (1) SA 740 (T) | Distinguished security vs. outright cession. |
| FNB v Lynn NO | 1996 (2) SA 339 (A) | Interpreted the consequences of cession during insolvency. |
| Hutchison and Pretorius | The Law of Contract in South Africa | General contract principles including cession. |
Useful Links
South African Legal Information Institute (SAFLII) – Access to full-text legal decisions.
Parliamentary Monitoring Group – Useful for understanding proposed statutory changes that may affect cession.
OpenBylaws South Africa – Helpful for accessing bylaws that may impact local contractual enforcement.
If you would like to know more about the doctrine of fictional fulfilment, please click here.
If you would like to know more about the binding effects of roman law click here.
If you would like to know more about specific performance as a remedy please click here.
If you would like to know more about the effect of suspension conditions please click here.
If you would like to know more about amendments to contracts click here.
If you would like to better understand the concept of novation click here.
If you would like to know more about waiver please click here.
If you would like to learn how to effectively cancel a contract click here.
If you would like to know more about the proper way to read a contract click here.
If you would like to know more about the concept of sett-off click here.
If you would like to know more about the authority to sign documents of security click here.
Meyer and Partners Attorneys have offices in Centurion and can assist with all of your Family Law, Civil Law, Contractual, and labour-related matters.
This article is a general information sheet and should not be used or relied on as legal or other professional advice. No liability can be accepted for errors, omissions, loss, or damage arising from reliance upon any information herein. Don’t hesitate to contact Meyer and Partners Attorneys Incorporated if you require further information or specific and detailed advice. Errors and omissions excepted (E&O E).